Monday, 21 August 2017

National Anthem during movie

This piece has numerous quotations from famous men. Despite many iterations, I could not reduce further. To be sure, my thoughts on the subject have not been influenced by these quotes, if anything, the quotes have been chosen to reaffirm my views. Thus the selection is biased. While I am sure there would be many quotations to the contrary from equally worthy and distinguished people, these are chosen to convey my thoughts on the subject. To read only the quotes and skip the text would not be the worst idea.

“You'll never have a quiet world till you knock the patriotism out of the human race.”
― George Bernard Shaw

What is patriotism? Online dictionary definition is: “Having or expressing devotion to and vigorous support for one's country.” For me, this definition has some problems. First, does the support have to be vigorous? How does one measure vigour? Does less vigour mean less patriotism? Second, how does one define a person who is not devoted and not vigorously supporting? Is he a ‘traitor’? Or can one be apatriotic? Is there even such a term? I have often pondered on patriotism. Is it a virtue and is it a necessary virtue? When we are young, love for the country is imbibed into us by way of songs and stories of country’s glory. (In cases like mine, it may not be so much a part of upbringing at home.) As we grow older and start to think, we question many things including patriotism. My thought process on this topic has evolved on multiple lines -

In my personal experience I have not found many patriotic people. Largely that has to do with the social surrounding. I feel, in India, patriotism is not uniformly distributed, rather it follows racial or geographical lines. If presence in the armed forces can be used as a proxy for degree of patriotism (I know it is far from perfect, but a crude proxy), Indian armed forces has significantly higher representation from Punjabis, Jats, people from J&K, Himachal Pradesh, Gurkhas, Marathas, than say Gujaratis, Bengalis, Oriya, Biharis or the Baniya communities populating the states of Rajasthan, and Madhya Pradesh. I come from the Marwari clan (a Baniya community) and I doubt there would be many marwaris in armed forces (too self-centered, risk-averse where physical safety is concerned and focused on amassing wealth). Like many other virtues, for Baniya, patriotism is a fine trait, but only when followed by others. In my community I have never come across anyone or even heard anybody display any act of valour. Outside my community as well, I have heard few stories of people in the armed forces. I suppose it is usual - Indian armed forces including paramilitary forces has strength of 4-5 million which is less than 0.5% of the population. Nevertheless, to me patriotism has largely been a distant concept. It is a bit unnerving when one reads of families dedicating generations to armed forces, or of stories of how selflessly people fight in wars. I have developed a cynicism towards patriotism, part of which is justified as I would elaborate further.  

“There is no flag large enough to cover the shame of killing innocent people.”
― Howard Zinn (American historian, playwright, and social activist)

“He who joyfully marches to music rank and file has already earned my contempt. He has been given a large brain by mistake, since for him the spinal cord would surely suffice. This disgrace to civilization should be done away with at once. Heroism at command, senseless brutality, deplorable love-of-country stance and all the loathsome nonsense that goes by the name of patriotism, how violently I hate all this, how despicable and ignoble war is; I would rather be torn to shreds than be part of so base an action!”
― Albert Einstein

“Patriotism is the virtue of the vicious”
― Oscar Wilde

“The notion that a radical is one who hates his country is naïve and usually idiotic. He is, more likely, one who likes his country more than the rest of us, and is thus more disturbed than the rest of us when he sees it debauched. He is not a bad citizen turning to crime; he is a good citizen driven to despair.”
― H.L. Mencken (American journalist, satirist, cultural critic)

“All wars are civil wars because all men are brothers... Each one owes infinitely more to the human race than to the particular country in which he was born.”
― François Fénelon

“Patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel.”
― Samuel Johnson (English writer, poet, essayist, moralist, literary critic, biographer, editor and lexicographer)

“What struck me as I began to study history was how nationalist fervor - inculcated from childhood on by pledges of allegiance, national anthems, flags waving and rhetoric blowing - permeated the educational systems of all countries, including our own. I wonder now how the foreign policies of the United States would look if we wiped out the national boundaries of the world, at least in our minds, and thought of all children everywhere as our own. Then we could never drop an atomic bomb on Hiroshima, or napalm on Vietnam, or wage war anywhere, because wars, especially in our time, are always wars against children, indeed our children.”
― Howard Zinn, A People's History of the United States

“If our country is worth dying for in time of war let us resolve that it is truly worth living for in time of peace.”
― Hamilton Fish (American statesman and politician)

“Patriotism is a kind of religion; it is the egg from which wars are hatched."
― Guy de Maupassant, The Complete Short Stories Vol. 2 of 3

“My wariness of patriotism comes from the tribalism that creeps alongside it and the Us and Them divisions it inevitably creates. There's an undeniable appeal to tribal membership, of course. We all want to be part of the club, however we define it.”
Chris A. Smith "Angels, Protesters and Patriots: What a Long-Ago Skirmish Says About Love of Country", California Magazine, March 29, 2016

Does patriotism imply violence? I think the whole concept of patriotism has been introduced and enforced to mobilise people to protect territories. What is the concept of a nation-state? Or a country? Ever since man turned from a hunter-gatherer to an agriculturist, the concept of owning and protecting a territory gained root. Man is a social animal but he is not boundlessly social - one tends to conjoin with certain kinds. Starting with a family, the concept snowballs into a locality, a community, a village, a town, a state and ultimately a country. That is largely where the affinity stops (only attack by aliens may unite us). Even animals exhibit preservation of territory. It is largely this love of territory - what is mine, that is exalted to patriotism. And preservation of territory requires violence - against outsiders, invaders. Greed in humans means that he wants more than what he has and that extends to land. Since earliest history, men have tried to amass land - apart from the economic prosperity or access to something specific (gold, timber, fertile soil, water, iron, cotton), size of one’s territory has been a sign of strength. This implies a territory and its natives are constantly under threat from invaders and thus it is necessary to protect it (imagine if someone pitched his tent in your home, you would surely turn to violence). So violence is at the core of patriotism. Turning the coin, patriotism is an easy tool to invoke and justify violence. And there have been many instances when this has happened.     

“Patriotism is a double-edged sword. It both emboldens the blood and narrows the mind.”
― Anonymous

“Patriotism: Your conviction that this country is superior to all other countries because you were born in it.”
― George Bernard Shaw, The Public: A Journal of Democracy, 1910

Patriotism is like a faith and just like faith can make one blind, so can patriotism. It narrows thinking. It can force one to accept without questioning. It is very easy to slip from patriotism to jingoism. This is readily seen in the world everyday when people fall readily to the cry of patriotism by some partisan leader without considering the merits. And the love for the country is so deeply embedded that patriotism becomes a very potent and dangerous tool. Even educated, free thinkers feel weak to speak against a foul-cry of patriotism.

“I love America more than any other country in the world and, exactly for this reason, I insist on the right to criticize her perpetually.”
― James Baldwin (American writer and social critic)

“The greatest patriotism is to tell your country when it is behaving dishonorably, foolishly, viciously.”
― Julian Barnes (English writer), Flaubert's Parrot

“Patriotism is a lively sense of collective responsibility. Nationalism is a silly cock crowing on its own dunghill and calling for larger spurs and brighter beaks.”
― Richard Aldington (English poet and writer), The Colonel's Daughter

Patriotism is proud of a country's virtues and eager to correct its deficiencies; it also acknowledges the legitimate patriotism of other countries, with their own specific virtues. The pride of nationalism, however, trumpets its country's virtues and denies its deficiencies, while it is contemptuous toward the virtues of other countries. It wants to be, and proclaims itself to be, "the greatest," but greatness is not required of a country; only goodness is.
― Sydney J. Harris (American journalist), Pieces of Eight

“Patriotism is when love of your own people comes first; nationalism, when hate for people other than your own comes first”
― Charles de Gaulle

“Such then is the human condition, that to wish greatness for one's country is to wish harm to one's neighbors.”
― Voltaire

I feel true patriotism should allow one to say that my country is not good at something or even that another country is better. Just like in most aspects of life, appreciation of somebody better is accepted, why not within countries. Why can I not say that this is the problem with my country and another is doing much better job than ours. Increasingly in India, it is seen as anti-national. It is seen that criticising something demeans it, or weakens it, without even going into the merit of the criticism. It is a perfect ostrich approach in which entire India is engulfed. While we are not an autocratic country and there is a degree of tolerance for the unpopular and dismissive cries, but that tolerance seems to be waning. There have been numerous incidents when dissidents to patriotic virtues, in the field of arts, literature, politics, are being marginalised and criminalised. Words like Nationalism and anti-National are easily thrown around.

“I saw courage both in the Vietnam War and in the struggle to stop it. I learned that patriotism includes protest, not just military service”
― John F. Kerry

“How does one hate a country, or love one?... I know people, I know towns, farms, hills and rivers and rocks, I know how the sun at sunset in autumn falls on the side of a certain plowland in the hills; but what is the sense of giving a boundary to all that, of giving a name and ceasing to love where the name ceases to apply? What is the love of one's country; is it hate of one's uncountry? Then it's not a good thing.”
― Ursula K. Le Guin (American author), The Left Hand of Darkness

To take this further, it is unpatriotic or even seditious to say that another country is better. It is unpatriotic even not to criticise and speak against, vehemently and vociferously, certain countries, who are rivals. This brand of patriotism thrives on appearing superior by making others inferior. In India, “My country great” is a common refrain. So it is to pull down the British for colonising us, Pakistan for its very existence, most of western countries for their supposed cultural vacuity, African countries for their relative economic weakness and colour. It is all very neat - those who are inferior are easily dismissed, and those who are economically superior we play the culture argument, that too largely perceived and on many occasions devoid of facts.   

“People who enjoy waving flags don't deserve to have one”
― Banksy (anonymous England-based graffiti artist, political activist and film director of unverified identity), Wall and Piece

“Identification with the rag called the national flag is an emotional and sentimental factor and for that factor you are willing to kill another - and that is called, the love of your country, love of the neighbor . . .?”
― Jiddu Krishnamurti (Indian philosopher, speaker and writer)

“Patriotism is like religion - it is best when least ostentatious.”
― Charles E. Jefferson, "Ethical Aspects of Conscription and the War"

“Patriotism is being refashioned as a performance sport. It is not a feeling, it is an act, and it has to be performed in public view over and over again.”
― Sandip Roy, Huffington Post, March 21, 2016

The kind of patriotism that India is focused on is presentative. And given our love for superficiality, we are accepting it with glory. It is the latest buzzword, a fad, a brand which somebody has decided to peddle. The millenial population of this country is largely devoid of thought, unaided by the poor education system, lacks focus, has short attention span, is consumer of instant sensory pleasure, and is aspirational only for material gains. Thus it is easy to peddle most things as fashion and patriotism too falls in that bucket. At one point we had a law which prohibited waving the national flag at civilian houses or vehicles. The argument was that it tantamounted to, or at least led to, the possibility of disrespect of the national flag. The law made no sense and a few years back the restriction was removed, following a Public Interest Litigation in the Supreme Court. So now one can easily put the national flag on vehicle, at house or hold it anywhere. Good, respectful and patriotic all. But it is becoming too showy, too pretentious. In another recent development, it is mandatory to play the national anthem before the start of a movie in cinema halls. While it is not said, I think it is by dictum of public conduct, essential to stand during the playing of the anthem. Again all showy for me. It was recently decided by government universities to hoist the national flag in campuses, possibly to counter the rising tide of anti-nationalism amongst youth. Whatever happened to free will, free speech, free thought? It is like patriotism is being stuffed down the throat; nationalism is a software program to be installed. In India it is common to give the argument of ‘impressionable minds’. That every non-adult is under a threat of being impressed upon with evil/seditious/anti-nationalistic thoughts and it is essential to guard them against these through brute force. Thus it is essential to have flags all around. To stop all flow of information which is inglorious for the country. My only argument is against the use of ‘force’. I should have the freedom to act the way I like - stand to national anthem if I like and sit if I do not. Not giving respect should not be counted as disrespect. And I should have the freedom to form and own my opinions.

“Patriotism … is a superstition artificially created and maintained through a network of lies and falsehoods; a superstition that robs man of his self-respect and dignity, and increases his arrogance and conceit.”
― Emma Goldman (anarchist political activist and writer)

“So I wonder why patriotism is judged by words and not deeds? Why are slogans more important than solutions? …. I wonder why we are not asked to display our nationalism by being told to harvest rain water, use less plastic, and recycle so that we actually nurture our land, instead of just paying lip service and bandying a few words around.”
― Twinkle Khanna

“Patriotism is a sore subject with me. We have the flag-waving loudmouth patriot who never sacrificed a thing for this country. We have the sidearm-carrying patriot who thinks playing cowboy is a substitute for patriotism. We have the moneyed, connected types who automatically consider themselves patriots. We have people who had a great-great-grandfather who ... and on and on and on.”
― Paul Sypek, "Missing The Character Of True Patriotism", Hartford Courant, March 28, 2016

Is saluting the national flag, standing while playing of the national anthem, or even singing it along, the most patriotic thing? This is where patriotism in India largely starts from and ends. I am sure many of those who diligently respect the national anthem in a cinema hall, and even look sternly at those who do not, would push and jostle to get out of the hall once the movie is over, would try to rush out of the parking lot, honk ceaselessly on the road, jump red light if required, try to bribe the policeman if caught, throw garbage in public places, try to jump the queue at the entrance of restaurant, work air conditioners of home on stolen electricity, mistreat their maids or attendants of any kind. And these are just minor offences - the same people would evade taxes, thrive in and advance the culture of corruption in their businesses or professions, allow their minor kids to drive vehicles on the road rashly and even injure a few people, be least concerned about reducing the air and water pollution. These same people would adulterate food that harms and kills millions, make poor roads on which people die in accidents, sell spurious medicines, occupy seats of power on sheer muscle and financial strength at the expense of deserving people, attack foreigners of particular nationality or colour if it does not suit their tastes or sensibilities, allow mounds of garbage to pile up as long it is outside the gated societies they live in. In their conduct, the focus is solely on the safety and prosperity of self, family and dear ones. Or if they are slightly more socially aware and responsible, than they work for their religious or caste groups. Which itself might involve pulling down other religions and castes. And of course, a large part of them would profess patriotism on social media, proudly forward messages, even wear the team shirt and bash the arch-rival Pakistan during a cricket match. Patriotism in India is mere public lip service while actual efforts are too difficult and inconveniencing - best left to somebody else.   

“....The gospel of the monarchical patriotism is: "The King can do no wrong." We have adopted it with all its servility, with an unimportant change in the wording: "Our country, right or wrong!" We have thrown away the most valuable asset we had: the individual's right to oppose both flag and country when he (just he, by himself) believed them to be in the wrong. We have thrown it away; and with it all that was really respectable about that grotesque and laughable word, Patriotism.”
― Mark Twain

“The love of one's country is a splendid thing. But why should love stop at the border.”      
― Pablo Casals   

Sunday, 23 July 2017

Dunkirk - Movie Review

War movies are about hope and heroes. And Dunkirk has both. But it does not preach heroism. If anything, the movie is very low on dialogues. In fact there are not even meaningful glances, hat tips, or gestures of bravado. The movie is a matter-of-fact portrayal of an important chapter of the Second World War. As director Christopher Nolan said: “It was an important story to be told”. And he tells it well. Cerebrally, it is the simplest Nolan movie - this is about the heart and not the mind.

Dunkirk incident is before the Fall of France, the horrors of concentration camps, and the glory at Normandy. In the early part of the war, the British and French forces are pushed to the French north-coast by the advancing German army (just referred to as the ‘enemy’). The soldiers are trapped on the beach of Dunkirk waiting for rescue, or ‘deliverance’ as the movie puts it. The enemy is in such a strong position and the British air and navy so disadvantaged that it is estimated that barely 40,000 out of 400,000 would be evacuated. The fact that by the end, more than 300,000 are evacuated is what is called the Miracle of Dunkirk.

The war is being fought on land, sea and air and the movie makes three neat sections for them with a little joining of dots in the end to give coherence. Each section is headed by a major actor – Kenneth Branagh on land (or the Mole, name given to the pier which extends into the sea), Thomas Hardy in air and Mark Rylance in the sea. It is a movie by a British director, with largely a British crew, showcasing British valour. For the British soldiers, rescue means transportation across the Channel and the movie squarely focuses on them (French army is stopped from boarding the British evacuation ship). ‘Home’ is barely a few miles away and more than one character says ‘It is so close, you can almost see it’.  

The movie is not as hard hitting as a Schindler’s List or a Saving Private Ryan, but neither is it kitschy. It is taut, well-paced and true to the story. And dialogues, being minimal, are punchy. Only towards the end does the sheen of steadfastness crack with indulgence into heroism, giving some lose moments I felt. But that is the path the movie had to take. The first half of the movie is plain, factual and exact, the audience knows that it is not that difficult movie. Then the second half had to give a victory, a lofty pat on the back. In the cinema hall, after the first half, a group near me was totally bored. By the end of the movie, another group could not help but clap when the evacuation succeeded.

Focusing on a few soldiers and their struggle to find a way to safety, Dunkirk presents the tension of those few days tersely. Two soldiers desperately cling onto a medical stretcher as a way to freedom, then on to a large vessel which is torpedoed, then back to Dunkirk, then hiding inside a stranded ship waiting for the tide to come back instead becoming shooting practise for the Germans, then stranded in an oil spill and finally rescued by a small pleasure-boat. But at all times, the tension is under the surface. It can be deduced only from worried faces - of the soldiers, of the Commander on the Mole, of Mr. Dawson on the boat and of Farrier in his Spitfire. Yet everyone holds on to their positions unflinchingly. Only on two occasions does the tension simmer to the surface, which is a far cry from most war movies wherein almost each scene is about conflict – of battle or of people desperate for survival. But Dunkirk goes about its business without fuss. There are numerous shots of long queues of soldiers and how they duck, sway, and shake with each torpedo attack before retaking their position - stoically, and steadfastly. For a war movie, this one has no blood, sweat or tears - neither of desolation nor of loss. Death is not pondered upon. Even towards the end when the Naval Commander wants to stay back on the mole ‘to help the French’, the Army Colonel just makes a respectful gesture before saluting off.

Central to the Dunkirk evacuation was the courage of the humble boat owners who answered Navy’s desperate call for help. And Mark Rylance’s Mr. Dawson exemplified that. He has the most dialogues and the does the most explaining, if at all. I found the ‘Sea’ part the best because of him and because of the courage of young, untrained, patriotic British, epitomised by Peter and George. They were not thinking but just going with the flow, driven by their hearts.

The end part has several beautiful moments – excerpt of the famous Churchill ‘We will fight them on the beaches’ speech; a soldier’s doubt on the worthless endeavour he had undertaken, saying “All we did was survive”, but the old, blind man who is cheering and distributing bread to the evacuated soldiers at night responds “That’s enough”. It showed the combined doggedness of a nation willing to stand together, overlooking personal misfortunes and miseries. The same thing shone when Peter does not tell the evacuated soldier that George has died after he pushed him, because that would torture the soldier for life.   

Finally, a hat tip to the music which can be integral to a movie with few dialogues. Hans Zimmer creates tension and victory with his music.   

Wednesday, 19 July 2017

A Day in School

It has been 17 years since I left school. In all these years I have been to the school not more than four times. Of the three educational phases in my life - school, college and post graduation, I enjoyed school the most. Being a sincere, hard-working student, I never dreaded school. I enjoyed everything - smell of new books, starting with a fresh register, sharpening pencils, filling ink in pens, buying new pens, creative project work, drawing, cutting, pasting, fevicol on fingers, maths problems, writing on blackboard, making artwork for bulletin board, lunch time, chatting between periods, arguing with teachers, parent-teacher meetings, loitering in school park during lunch time, extensive preparations for the Annual Day, waiting for bus at early morning, sweating in class during summers, helping out friends (partially) during exams, expectation when the exam answer sheets are distributed, all the teachers…

Yet it sounds so brutal and strange that I severed the link with school easily and never turned back. During a music class in my early years (class fifth, sixth or seventh), the music teacher, who was liked by all the students a lot, started to reminisce. During the class, a senior student just ran across the corridor and the teacher saw him from the open door. On seeing him rush past the classroom without a word, the teacher said wistfully something to the effect ‘That boy who just ran past was my student till some years back. When they were attending their last music class, they proclaimed with excitement that we would come and meet you regularly Maam. But nobody ever does. I see him passing the corridor frequently and he never peeps in to say hello’. Hearing this, all we kids thought, and some even said, ‘Don’t worry Maam, we are different, we would definitely come to meet you even after you are no longer teaching us’. But I am sure the teacher, being mature, did not harbour much hopes. And we were too young to know any better.

This was when I was still in school but would rarely go and meet my old teachers. What to say of going back after leaving the school. I know that I paint a picture grimmer than reality for many people - there are many enthusiastic, vivacious people who go back to their alma mater and reconnect with the teachers. But it has been different in my own experience and what I have seen with most of my friends. Sadly for me this has been true not just for school but also for graduation and post graduation. I have never kept touch with the institutions after leaving them. So no place for any sentimentality, it was a purely a commercial transaction - I paid fees and I got education. Mind you, I am not talking about going to the institution in physical sense. I am talking about keeping a connection with people there - the teachers, who at one point were the most important part of my life.

For me, I can say that even when I had the feeling or longing to meet my teachers, I was diffident. Or I felt incapable of handling a situation wherein the teachers would not recognise me. This would have been definitely true with graduation and post-graduation teachers wherein I did not leave much of a mark to be remembered by them. But I am sure my school teachers would have recognised me had I followed up. But I did not. I got too busy making a career and nobody nudged me in that direction. I also thought that teachers may not be interested in keeping any contact and I would be impressing on them unnecessarily. Nevertheless, all these were my mental deterrents but I have seen most of my friends, who I think do not face similar impediments, behave similarly. Very few keep contact with old teachers. I wonder why. Mostly it is the passage of time erasing old memories to make space for new ones, the process of moving on. Also, I believe there is a degree of selfishness. Many people keep contact with the teachers of higher education because they have some relevance - giving referral for a job, mentoring for further education, opening doors to distinguished people in the field, giving opportunities for teaching in the institute, other career prospects etc. But a relatively humble school teacher does not offer any such benefit for future and thus not remembered. Such is the brutal reality of most things in life, most pertinently in the present times.

I have been holding these thoughts for many years. And I have fostered a feeling of incompleteness, of treachery, and of lacking. At the same time I never had any burning desire to correct this. It was not much weight on my conscience. I have attended two alumni meets of my MBA college in last 10 years and never talked to any of the ex-teachers. Even most of the batchmates I have barely acknowledged. I mostly spend time with people I was comfortable with during the student days, remember old acquaintances and show enthusiasm for where they are now, feel nostalgic for the campus and the time spent, and then come home. I always felt uneasy about this attitude but not much. The last alumni I attended with a best friend, and we had a great time, though along the similar lines as I have enumerated above. But he was very animated and kept saying as we were loitering around the campus remembering old days: ‘Gosh! This is so great. So many years gone by. It feels so wonderful. We should come here atleast once a year’. And I had that all-knowing, monk-like, half-smile on my face, saying to myself ‘We shall see’.

But I have had greater longing for my school. Over the last few years I have felt, swayed by the more experiential MBA education, that school education was so bookish. I had so few life-skills, such limited knowledge of career options when I left school. I felt that school children can benefit immensely from experiences of their alumni. I often desired to stand before a class and freely share my thoughts. Indeed I want to do something in the field of education as I feel that I can genuinely contribute. But as is usually the case with me, I have not done much about these desires. Recently, I got to know of an alumni meeting in school. This got me interested and I went for it. While not much, I had expected a reasonable number of ex-students to turn up, at least in double digits. As it happened, there were five of us, three  coming for the first time and out of nostalgic excitement like me. The other two were regular and I came to know that they hold this meeting every month. So we went to a new section of the school where I had not been before. As we were talking amongst ourselves, four teachers joined, two of whom I knew well and thought they also recalled me. But they did not betray any sign of recognition or even if they recognised, they did not show any inclination to talk personally. I felt a bit dejected but did not initiate conversation myself, out of some hesitation.

Anyway, the agenda of the meeting was to plan for an alumni sports day in a month’s time. Apparently, the idea had been under discussion for some time but the two alumni veterans had not been able to cover much ground. What I gathered from the discussion was that the idea was pretty grand and I felt that there was absolutely no preparation to pull it off. At the end of this meeting, the newbies amongst us shared our business cards with the teacher whom I had recognised. She had taught me till my last days in school. As I gave her my card I was expecting some signs of recognition and interest but none came. Again, even if there was recognition there was definitely no interest in knowing how has the life been since our paths diverged. She read my business card and kept it, without any inclination to know more about my organisation or industry. I was dejected.

But why? Had I shared an emotional connect with the teachers, I would have come much earlier. I have been busy, selfish. So why this disappointment? I think for students, school is an important phase of life, when they were impressionable, when most of their thoughts are formed, an age of innocence and unique experiences which make up vivid memories. Students get nostalgic about it and nostalgia is always beautiful. But for teachers, they have always been here only. Students come and go and some come back. The teachers do not share the same sentimentality. I feel the teachers get hardened after years of not being followed up on by their students. It is stupid of me to expect enthusiasm from them after 17 years, when I had not called upon them once. Still I think that I should have at least asked ‘Maam, do you recognise me?’

Moving on, we went to the principal’s room to discuss the event further. I kept thinking that during my 12 years in school I have been inside this room only once, or at most twice. The principal had changed from our times, and from what I had heard, for the worse. Almost unanimous opinion was that the principal at our time was much better and things have definitely gone downhill since he left, although the school still ranked amongst the best in the vicinity. Hearing this principal at close quarters reminded me of meeting with another school principal I had had a few years back as part of my job. There was a similarity about the passion with which they talked. They are so enthusiastic about their work, thinking about the children and how to make their school better. So we had a good half an hour discussion wherein the principal highlighted the need to have more active alumni involvement. This I agreed with wholeheartedly. My school lacks a structured alumni program with strong connections, regular events and contributions from the alumni. Indeed, this has been the case with all my educational institutions. Why me? Am I some sort of a jinx? Or I end up in places where all people have the traits of lethargy, inaction and hesitation just like me. Some kind of ‘Birds of a feather flock together’ working on institutional scale.

The date of the Sports Day was finalised in the meeting and we left the principal’s office. But not before I had given my suggestion of having sessions where alumni talks to the students and shares their experiences in life and careers. Outside the principal’s cabin we alumni huddled in the reception area while the teachers left in a jiffy. Herein I tried to probe from the two active members into the workings of the alumni committee. Skeletons fell out and pole-danced. The fact that the committee was in disjointed shape was apparent to me but I realised that in fact it is more of a concept. I was told that they do not have any representation from many past batches. They had busy lives and alumni activity tended to take to backseat. So nobody was fully committed to the cause. I thought it was obvious, most of them have personal and professional commitments and it is difficult to contribute to a social activity than an urgent requirement. Who was I to judge? I myself had never contributed to a social cause. I wanted to get into that - be part of some management task but was doubting my abilities.

Discussion with these people brought out more rot. They mentioned that school itself was not cooperative. I was aghast to know that the school did not have a comprehensive list of old students, which I thought would have been a good starting place to organise the alumni. I was keen on first having a solid database as foundation on which to build the alumni network. It was mentioned that there is a lot of political tension amongst the teachers and the principal and things are not what they seem on the surface. On the alumni side, there is a feeling that the school itself does not want to connect with them. And also the problem of dis-interest. Students come forward only when they have a benefit to derive - networking or getting admission of their kids.

Overall, this discussion left me bemused. My enthusiasm to contribute was deflated after hearing about these political shenanigans and selfishness behind the whole effort. To add to that, the coldness of the teachers who did not seem much eager to collaborate with the alumni dampened my spirits. The environment was of mutual cynicism. I realised I was naive to expect something totally different. Any group of people is bound to have political interplay which one is required to navigate. I had expected the field of education to be simpler than the corporate world but it was a stupid belief - education sector is also composed of people who have aspirations, biases, motives, and self-interests. Nevertheless, I was most disappointed to note that selfishness is so rampant - I am not able to find any place without it.

In the end, I spent more time with one of my batch mate who was an active alumni. She filled me with more developments and how the school has changed, more like how the thought process had changed. One example of change was that the girls now had to wear salwar-kameez instead of skirts. I asked her with abject displeasure as to why did we (the school that is) get so regressive. She said that it was necessitated because of changing times, hinting at the need to keep a tighter control on adolescent students. I said that romances were common even during our times. She said it has deteriorated significantly, and mentioned CCTV footages. This made me realise my naivety yet again. We reminisced about good old days - about batch mates, about teachers, about how we had simple upbringing, about how we were willing to sweat. Still, some things had changed for the better - students have so much more exposure, career alternatives have multiplied, there was focus on extracurricular activities, and personality development. It was a departure from the bookish, academic focus we had. She mentioned how the teachers have been told to converse in English only as it was felt that our students were inferior in English communication skills and came across as unrefined in comparison to students of other schools. All in all, I left with a queer, dissatisfied feeling. I questioned if I was cut out for all this, for this world! Still I was happy to interact with a new set of people in unfamiliar setting.    

Sunday, 16 July 2017

A Cynic's Friendship

Me: What kind of friendships are there?
Not Me: Why do all things have to be labelled?
Me: Why not? I like to label stuff. It makes one reflect, understand and improve. Anyway, it seems to be a good point to start a debate.
Not Me: you would not stop! You tell me. What kind of friendships are there?
Me: I don’t know myself but I ruminate. Fair weather friend is a well-known kind. Then there are those whom you have just for fun, nothing much expected, but they are good to spend some leisure time. Yet another kind would be the agony-aunt or sounding-board types - those who are reliable for a good advice and on odd occasion for a shoulder to cry on. And some friends you keep just to feel superior about - in whose company you don’t feel challenged.
Not Me: interesting! Never thought there would be so many. I only thought of a true friend and a not-true friend.
Me: I am always bemused by the concept of true friend. Is there any such thing?
Not Me: Why not? Why do you say so?
Me: Hmmm… How do I explain? To call something true is to consider it ‘pure’ and in relationships I feel only blood ties can be pure, if at all. Is it possible for a friendship to be selfless? To have no ulterior motive?
Not Me: What motive?
Me: Oh that can be anything. Something trivial like having a good time. Or for intellectual enrichment. Or money. Or greater gains.
Not Me: Oh but why! Why can’t a thing just be?
Me: But what value to give to a thing that just is. Friendship should have some value.
Not Me: It is your own calculative mind. Friendship has a value, but that value is friendship itself. Friendship does not happen to justify any value.
Me: I cannot make sense of that. We chose friends. They are not forced onto us like most relations.
Not Me: But you just said, blood lines are the purest.
Me: Do you not feel the same way yourself? The feelings for mother, father, sister, brother, son, daughter are the strongest.
Not Me: I agree. Our parents are our first human contact and the feeling for them grows because of the love and protection that we get from them. With siblings, love comes from shared traits, growing up together, the comfort of commonality.
Me: And kids!
Not Me: I am not sure where the love for kids originates from? For the mother, possibly it emanates from the pain of pregnancy and childbirth. But more than that I think the love for a kid comes from a sense of protection - when you hold a fragile being, whose eyes are just curious, who cannot walk, who cannot talk, who is trying to make sense of this world - you just want to protect that kid.
Me: I want to ask where does love for a spouse originate, but I do not want to start a sub-argument here.
Not Me: Oh good. Now back to the topic of friendship. Blood lines being pure does not rule out anything else becoming equally pure. Why not friends?
Me: before I proceed, let me add I do not say blood relations are always the purest. Many a times we carry on with them because societal norms force us to. It becomes difficult to admit that you do not have the same warmth.
Not Me: pray do not digress.
Me: alright. I think I am driven in my thoughts by my experiences. Somehow I have always found friendships to have a degree of selfishness, a quid-pro-quo which puts me at discomfort.
Not Me: How unfortunate! I believe friendships originate from an innate desire for companionship. And in that sense there is a mutual affinity.
Me: I do not disagree to that. But that affinity stops at personal wishes and constraints. And thus the friendship does not achieve the selflessness which you so profess.
Not Me: How did you make friends in the first place? Was there always a motive?
Me: No. Consciously I grew closer to certain people whose thoughts I could relate to, whose company I enjoyed, with whom I could have intellectual or emotional oneness.
Not Me: So, there it is. You are talking about true friends, without any motive.
Me: But essentially what I am talking about is having a good time with friends. I always had the impression, possibly due to movies, books and nice catch-phrases that friendship is more. I realised that when I wanted to take my friendships to the next level I could not. I wanted to be able to lean on the other person or even to be his support, but it never happened. I always had a feeling of superficiality about the friendships. Possibility it was something lacking in me.  
Not Me: It may be possible that you expect too much. Why can’t you accept what you get?
Me: I can but what is the fun in that. Let me quote an incident. Long back I was visiting a cousin. While chatting, comparison of respective friends came up. We were trying to get one up on the other. After some jostling, my cousin threw the decisive blow. He asked ‘‘my friend would travel 100 kms to run an errand if I ask him to, would your friend do the same?’ And I had no answer. I agreed that such a thing would not happen. Now this cousin lived in a small town, kind of where you know most people. I sensed in smaller places, people have lesser complex personal lives, more mental and physical bandwidth.  
Not Me: So now you are saying that purity of friendship varies according to the place?
Me: All I am saying is that in my experience I have found that big city life has its own pressures, it is so energy sapping, and that it becomes difficult to accommodate somebody else when you are barely able to meet your own needs.
Not Me: I believe you have been misguided by your poor experiences. Or possibly you yourself never invested into a friendship truly.
Me: I am perplexed. I feel I have always tried a lot. Indeed I have seen people have beautiful friendships where they are with each other through thick and thin. I have numerous memories of good times with friends but somehow I feel that beauty, dependability has been missing. To quote another example, somebody was recently relating his post-graduation times to me. He said “I made much stronger friendships during my graduation days than I could during post graduation. I did not like people around me during the post graduation. They were so ‘practical’”. And the word struck me. Yes, most of my friendships have been practical not emotional. And over the last few years things have worsened.  
Not Me: Why?
Me: I have drifted apart from many good friends. With some, the friendship has been lost for good.
Not Me: Continue.
Me: What to say! Misunderstandings aplenty. Friend-making ability is inversely proportional to the age. How easy it was to make friends when we are kids - you would talk to the person you were made to sit next to in a class. Similarly during college time, you made friends over a shared samosa. But it is so difficult to stay a child as you grow up. I doubt if I have made a close friend in last so many years.
Not Me: Yeah! With age grows our ego, our mind. We start to think, and overthink. We attach meaning to everything said and done. We are not willing to accept things and people on face value. How does one cope with lost friends?
Me: Move on. What else. That is what is the best about this life, this heart and this mind. It will always find a reason to move on. It has to, because there is no other option.
Not Me: So you just forget friends one fine day? How heartless!
Me: No. Of course you go through the painful transition, the pain which becomes severe when you do not understand what you did wrong. Or when you tried so hard to save the friendship.
Not Me: and when your efforts fail, do you just let go?
Me: you try and try and try and then you let go. You know after a point you just forget what went wrong in the first place. Because forgetting is a part of the process of moving on. So many layers of misunderstanding, miscommunication, perceptions, biases, irritations get added that you forget the kernel of the issue.
Not Me: But you said that there was a superficiality about the friendship. Then why so much fuss? Why could you not let go easily?
Me: I still say there was a superficiality. There was no dependability. It had always irked me that this is only a friendship of happiness. In trouble every one is on his own. I wanted to change that but it never happened.
Not Me: so now what?
Me: A silence. A numbness. Friends make you realise a part of you which you never knew existed. And when they go, the part goes with them, and you just feel stupid about the realisation. Eventually, we all get busy in the life, with responsibilities which we cannot throw away, playing roles which are our wont.  
Not Me: how disappointing! The more I think the more I realise you never understood friendship.
Me: I would say I never got the balance. At times I was too close to the book. And at times I was too distant.

Buran Ghati – a personal memoir

  (Written over 19-24 June 2025)     Phew! I have to write this. Buran Ghati was my fifth trek. And the fifth one with P and NS. Someone...